Unbalanced_Feature_03-2014

When it comes to trade, are rare earth metals any different from LNG?

The United States won a big victory for free trade this morning when the World Trade Organization upheld the U.S. challenge to China’s restrictions on the export of rare-earth metals.

The Obama administration should be applauded for pursuing this case. U.S. Trade Representative Michael Froman said the White House would “go to the mat for American workers and businesses to make sure that the playing field is fair and level.” That’s absolutely right.

UnbalancedFroman explained the administration’s motivation to press its case before the WTO:

China’s decision to promote its own industry and discriminate against U.S. companies has caused U.S. manufacturers to pay as much as three times more than what their Chinese competitors pay for the exact same rare earths.  WTO rules prohibit this kind of discriminatory export restraint and this win today, along with our win 2 years ago in an earlier case, demonstrates that clearly.

On a similar issue, however, it’s worth asking what makes China’s rare-earth metals protectionism any different from what the Obama administration is doing on liquefied natural gas (LNG) exports.

The administration’s exceedingly slow approach to permitting, which currently leaves more than two dozen proposed LNG export projects languishing in application limbo, serves the narrow, protectionist aims of a group of domestic energy consumers that I have written about before.

Curiously, one of those companies actively supported the U.S. case against China over rare earth metals. But when it comes to American LNG, it sings a different tune.

The administration’s go-slow policy is squandering commercial opportunities for American companies. At the same time it is denying the economy the stimulus that numerous experts claim will be generated by a liberalized policy that is consistent with trade in other domestic products.

Today’s rare-earths decision is particularly timely, coming just one day after the former chairman of the World Trade Organization’s appeals panel warned a congressional committee that the Obama administration’s approach to LNG exports likely violates WTO rules.

Let’s hope the administration recognizes the inconsistency of differing approaches on trade. It should grant approval to all of the proposed projects that are awaiting review, and let the market determine which ones will go forward. That would make sure “the playing field is fair and level,” to use Ambassador Froman’s words.

And it just might spare the United States a rebuke from the very same WTO that the administration this morning commended.


1 Comment

Already have a username? Log in to comment. First-time commenting? Sign up to create your username. It's easy, and we won't share your information.

  1. William Kandravi Jr. says:

    Rick Cohen I am glad to have the pleasure to leave you a message that is a game changer in you LNG/GAS MINERAL FIELD. I am in Oklahoma and I will make this short, I am a small investor and have invested in a company tat has future all over it. They are flying in on April 8,9, 10th to run a demonstration that is a a game changer in the LNG/GAS field . I will be happy to let you witness this of coarse a non disclosure would need to be signed , but that is all second hand, give me your word and I will set it so you can attend. This technology is already in use and the company is a 50 Mil $ Market Cap looking to grow, you will not have many chances to get in on ground floor opportunities lie this simply because of you size. They have several Multi Bil $ clients now and have not been bought out is because companies of similar stature as you off coarse smaller out source everything. This is is a no bull hi tech fossil fuel savior and could make a spark into a fire with you at Mobil. I will not say more if interested my e-mail is buffalokandravi@aol.com leave phone and extension and a time and I will call and fill you in. Might seem out of the ordinary but the other bidders are 26 Billion $ OUTFITS + BUT YOU WANT AN IDEA TO STAND OUT WORLD WIDE WITH DOMESTIC AND INTERNATIONAL PATENTS AND GOVT. APPROVAL FOR FUTURE RIGHTS TO ADD TO THERE PARTNERS E-MAIL ME. MY NAME IS BILL KANDRAVI YOU WANT SOMETHING THAT SHINES I HAVE THE TECHNOLOGY AND WISH TO STAY OUT OF IT , I WILL JUST PUT… read more »

    …THE FUTURE CLIENTS TOGETHER.
    SINCERELY
    BILL KANDRAVI
    buffalokandravi@aol.com do take a shot because you will see this later and end up a customer instead of an owner if you don’t.

  2. William Kandravi Jr. says:

    Rick Cohen I am glad to have the pleasure to leave you a message that is a game changer in you LNG/GAS MINERAL FIELD. I am in Oklahoma and I will make this short, I am a small investor and have invested in a company tat has future all over it. They are flying in on April 8,9, 10th to run a demonstration that is a a game changer in the LNG/GAS field . I will be happy to let you witness this of coarse a non disclosure would need to be signed , but that is all second hand, give me your word and I will set it so you can attend. This technology is already in use and the company is a 50 Mil $ Market Cap looking to grow, you will not have many chances to get in on ground floor opportunities lie this simply because of you size. They have several Multi Bil $ clients now and have not been bought out is because companies of similar stature as you off coarse smaller out source everything. This is is a no bull hi tech fossil fuel savior and could make a spark into a fire with you at Mobil. I will not say more if interested my e-mail is buffalokandravi@aol.com leave phone and extension and a time and I will call and fill you in. Might seem out of the ordinary but the other bidders are 26 Billion $ OUTFITS + BUT YOU WANT AN IDEA TO STAND OUT WORLD WIDE WITH DOMESTIC AND INTERNATIONAL PATENTS AND GOVT. APPROVAL FOR FUTURE RIGHTS TO ADD TO THERE PARTNERS E-MAIL ME. MY NAME IS BILL KANDRAVI YOU WANT SOMETHING THAT SHINES I HAVE THE TECHNOLOGY AND WISH TO STAY OUT OF IT , I WILL JUST PUT… read more »

    …THE FUTURE CLIENTS TOGETHER.
    SINCERELY
    BILL KANDRAVI
    buffalokandravi@aol.com do take a shot because you will see this later and end up a customer instead of an owner if you don’t.